How much will I save by switching from AfterSell?

Most brands save $1,500–$2,400 per year on app fees. AfterSell starts at $34.99/mo plus $99/mo for checkout features (~$134/mo total). Upsell Master starts at $9/mo with all features included, then scales based on upsell revenue we generate.

Will my customer-facing funnels look different?

Cleaner. Upsell Master renders inside Shopify's native checkout extension, so funnels match your brand fonts, colors, and spacing — unlike AfterSell's template-driven UI.

Upsell Master vs AfterSell

The AfterSell alternative built for cleaner funnels and fairer pricing

Same one-click post-purchase upsells. Brand-aligned funnel design that doesn't scream “third-party app.” A/B testing on every block — including checkout. From $9/month, not $34.99 + $99 for checkout.

Find us on the

Shopify App Store

Schedule A Demo

Trusted by Shopify Plus brands

SOTO GardensHANXand 100+ Shopify Plus brands

Pricing

Same outcomes, a fraction of the price

Most brands switching from AfterSell save $1,500–$2,400/year on app fees alone — before counting the AOV lift from cleaner, A/B-tested funnels.

Recommended

Upsell Master

$9/mo

Then revenue-based scaling. You only pay more when we make you more.

All features included from day one
Checkout customization on every plan
A/B testing on every funnel + every block
30-day free trial, no credit card
Cancel anytime

Start Free on Shopify

AfterSell

$34.99+/mo

Plus $99/month extra for the checkout-extension features. Real total: ~$134/mo for the full stack.

Checkout customization is a paid add-on
A/B testing is limited — not granular per-block
Pricing scales with order count, not value created
Funnel UI is template-driven, not brand-aligned
Migration assistance not included

Compare with our team

Why brands switch

Cleaner funnels. Fairer pricing. Deeper testing.

Cleaner, brand-aligned funnels

AfterSell's funnels are template-driven and look like a third-party app. Upsell Master renders inside Shopify's native checkout extension — your fonts, your colors, your spacing. Customers don't notice the upsell is “outside” the order.

Native to your brand

Pay only when you grow

AfterSell charges by order volume, regardless of whether the upsells convert. Upsell Master ties pricing to upsell revenue we generate — so the more we make you, the more we charge. Aligned incentives, not vendor margin.

Revenue-based pricing

A/B testing on every block

AfterSell A/B tests funnels at the offer level. Upsell Master tests every block — funnel offers, checkout trust badges, rewards bars, cart blocks — and gives you per-variant analytics. Purdy & Figg run it on their checkout Trust Badge block at 33.4% conversion.

Granular, not generic

Built on Shopify Plus rails

Native checkout extensions, no theme edits, no liquid hacks. Theme updates and refactors stay safe. Uninstalling Upsell Master leaves your storefront identical to how you found it. AfterSell still relies partly on theme injection for some features.

Zero theme conflicts

Feature-by-feature: Upsell Master vs AfterSell

Eight comparisons across post-purchase, checkout, A/B testing, analytics, and pricing — the metrics that actually move AOV and conversion.

Feature

Upsell Master

AfterSell

Post-purchase upsells

Included

Pre-purchase / cart upsells

Included

Checkout customization (Plus)

Trust badges, rewards, custom blocks

Add-on at +$99/mo

Stackable multi-step funnels

If/then conditional logic

Linear flows only

A/B testing scope

Per offer + per checkout block

Per offer only

Per-funnel analytics

Real-time + granular

Aggregate reporting

Funnel UI / brand fit

Native checkout extension

Template-driven

Pricing model

$9/mo + revenue-based

$34.99+/mo, $99 for checkout

Migration assistance

Included

Self-serve only

“

We tried two other upsell apps before Upsell Master. The funnels always looked like they belonged to someone else's brand. Upsell Master renders inside Shopify's native checkout — our customers can't tell where our checkout ends and the upsell begins. That's worth the switch alone.

Purdy & Figg

Growth Lead · Sunday Times Top 10 brand

Switching from AfterSell

Migrate in under a week — without breaking anything

Run both apps in parallel during the cutover. Zero downtime, no lost orders, no theme edits.

Install Upsell Master

Install from the Shopify App Store. Both apps run side by side — AfterSell keeps converting while you set up.

We map your existing funnels

Our onboarding team replicates every active AfterSell funnel inside Upsell Master — A/B variants and conditional logic intact.

Switch over in one click

Activate Upsell Master, deactivate AfterSell. Customer experience stays seamless. Most teams finish inside 5 days.

Talk to our migration team

FAQ: Switching from AfterSell

How much will I actually save by switching from AfterSell?

Most brands save $1,500–$2,400 per year on app fees alone. AfterSell starts at $34.99/mo and adds $99/mo for checkout customization features (real total: ~$134/mo for the full stack). Upsell Master starts at $9/mo with all features included, then scales based on the upsell revenue we generate. You only pay more when we make you more.

Can I migrate my existing AfterSell funnels without losing data?

Yes. Our onboarding team replicates every active AfterSell funnel inside Upsell Master — A/B variants and conditional logic intact — and runs both apps in parallel during the cutover. Most teams finish inside 5 days with zero downtime and no lost orders.

Will the funnels look different to my customers?

They'll look better. AfterSell uses template-driven funnel designs that customers often perceive as a third-party app. Upsell Master renders inside Shopify's native checkout extension architecture — your fonts, your colors, your spacing. The upsell feels like part of your checkout, not an external bolt-on.

What if my Shopify Plus subscription flow breaks?

It won't. Upsell Master sits on Shopify's official post-purchase extension, so your subscription checkout stays untouched. Purdy & Figg switched while running active subscriptions — zero disruption to the existing customer flow.

Is the A/B testing better than AfterSell's?

Yes — and the difference matters. AfterSell A/B tests at the offer level. Upsell Master tests every block — offers, checkout trust badges, rewards bars, cart blocks — with per-variant analytics. Purdy & Figg run it on their Trust Badge block at 33.4% conversion. SOTO Gardens runs eight funnel variants in parallel.

What does the migration support look like?

A 30-minute kickoff call to scope your existing AfterSell setup, then our team rebuilds your funnels inside Upsell Master and hands you a side-by-side QA preview. You activate when you're ready. No charge for migration assistance.

Ready to switch from AfterSell?

Same post-purchase upsells. Cleaner brand-aligned funnels. From $9/month.

Start Free on Shopify Schedule A Demo